Laboratory furniture tender: what to score beyond price
Tender evaluation criteria for laboratory furniture: technical parameters, warranty terms, service and life-cycle cost. How to describe them under Pzp.

Published: Updated Reading time: 9 min read
Contents
Tender evaluation criteria in a tender for laboratory furniture can reward quality, not only price. The Polish Public Procurement Law (Pzp) lists technical parameters, after-sales service, technical assistance and delivery conditions among the quality criteria. The criteria and their description should make it possible to verify and compare the level of workmanship offered, on the basis of the information given in the tenders (art. 240 ust. 2 Pzp).
What tender evaluation criteria does the Public Procurement Law allow?#
Pzp allows quality criteria alongside price or cost. Art. 242 ust. 2, quoted in the guide of the Public Procurement Office on non-price evaluation criteria (opens in a new tab), lists, among others, criteria relating to:
- quality, including technical parameters and aesthetic and functional properties, such as accessibility for people with disabilities;
- environmental aspects, including the energy efficiency of the subject of the contract;
- the organisation, qualifications and experience of the staff assigned to perform the contract, where they can significantly affect the quality of performance;
- after-sales service, technical assistance, delivery conditions, such as delivery time, and the performance period.
Criteria must relate to the subject of the contract and must not concern the properties of the contractor, in particular its economic, technical or financial reliability (art. 241). The UZP guide explains that the qualifications and experience of the staff assigned to perform the contract are not a criterion relating to the contractor.
How much weight can price have among the tender evaluation criteria?#
According to the UZP guide (opens in a new tab), public contracting authorities under art. 4 points 1 and 2 Pzp may give price a weight above 60% only on one condition (art. 246 ust. 2). In the description of the subject of the contract they must set quality requirements for at least the main elements of the contract. The same condition applies to price as the only criterion.
The guide also states a rule: the better the requirements are described in the conditions of the contract, the less need there is for quality criteria and the lower their weight. The contracting authority gives the weight of each criterion in the contract notice or in the procurement documents (art. 247 Pzp (opens in a new tab)). Requirements are easier to describe precisely when the laboratory design is complete, because the layout, utilities and types of workstations are then known before the tender is announced.
Instead of price, the contracting authority can assess cost, also by life-cycle costing (art. 245 Pzp (opens in a new tab)). The calculation covers, among others, the costs of acquisition, use, maintenance and end of life. According to our FAQ on how long laboratory furniture lasts, the countertop matters most.
What to score beyond price for laboratory furniture?#
You score what sets the tenders apart and what the contractor can state and document. The UZP guide advises avoiding criteria based on contractors' declarations that cannot be verified. For office furniture it adds that, beyond a description of basic technical parameters such as the type of material and fittings, you need criteria that tell high-quality products apart.
| Criterion | What the contractor states | How it is confirmed |
|---|---|---|
| countertop technical parameters | countertop material and its resistance to the laboratory's reagents | certificate or test report |
| workmanship | how the materials are joined, quality of the materials and drawer runners used | sample assessed by the committee |
| workstation functionality | meeting the users' needs, for example the layout of workstations and utilities | drawing or visualisation in the tender |
| warranty terms | period and scope of the warranty, service response time | entry in the tender and in the contract |
| after-sales service | post-warranty service and availability of spare parts | entry in the tender and in the contract |
The UZP guide gives an example for office furniture. The committee assesses the delivered furniture in sub-criteria such as workmanship, how the materials are joined, quality of the materials used and quality of the drawer runners. The guide adds that the contracting authority may also require a sample to be prepared. For laboratory furniture for schools, sub-criteria can also cover ease of cleaning and stability of the workstations, since many students use the same furniture.
Is the warranty period a good quality criterion?#
The warranty period alone is not enough. According to the UZP guide, if the warranty is meant to show quality, not only its period counts but also its terms. They include the scope of the warranty, warranty service, maximum response and repair time, and post-warranty service with spare parts available for many years.
The same goes for delivery time. The guide warns that promoting shorter performance times may lower the quality of workmanship. It is better to set the deadline as a requirement and give points for features of the furniture itself and of the service.
How to describe quality so the committee can compare tenders?#
The criteria and their description must make it possible to verify and compare the level of workmanship offered, on the basis of the information given in the tenders (art. 240 ust. 2 Pzp). The subject of the contract can be described by reference to Polish Standards that transpose European standards. Such a reference carries the words “or equivalent” (art. 101 Pzp (opens in a new tab)).
The materials in the example come from our FAQ, which names monolithic ceramic or epoxy resin for work with concentrated acids and solvents. The description of laboratory countertops helps you match the material to the reagents of a specific laboratory.
The contracting authority may require a certificate issued by a conformity assessment body or a report on tests carried out by that body (art. 105 Pzp (opens in a new tab)). A contractor who, through no fault of its own, cannot obtain them may submit other evidence, in particular the manufacturer's technical documentation. The required documents are given in the contract notice or in the procurement documents (art. 106 Pzp (opens in a new tab)).
What to look for when ordering Renggli laboratory furniture?#
Renggli laboratory furniture consists of RL1 to RL7 and RL Indywidual systems, on steel profiles, with ceramic or phenolic resin countertops. Our laboratory fume hoods meet EN 14175. On our company page we write that laboratory furniture is checked by a standard, not by the manufacturer's declaration.
For tender bids we provide the EN 14175-3 type test certificates and reports for our fume cupboards and the Renggli AG declaration of conformity.
After acceptance we stay with the laboratory: we service it, supply spare parts and upgrade workstations when the scope of research changes. The features worth describing in the specification are collected in our text on the features laboratory furniture should have.
Tender evaluation criteria: checklist before you publish the tender#
Before you publish a tender for laboratory furniture, check four things.
Describe the requirements
Enter in the description of the subject of the contract the standards with the words “or equivalent”, the countertop materials, the layout of the workstations and the delivery time.
Choose criteria that set tenders apart
Technical parameters above the minimum, workmanship assessed on a sample, warranty terms and after-sales service.
Assign weights and describe the scoring scale
Give the weight of each criterion and the scale by which the committee will award points on the basis of the information in the tender.
Name the documents
The contracting authority may require the contractors to submit a certificate issued by a conformity assessment body or a test report drawn up by that body. It accepts the manufacturer's technical documentation when the contractor has neither access to the certificates or reports nor the possibility of obtaining them within a suitable time, the lack of access cannot be attributed to the contractor, and the contractor proves that the supplies meet the requirements, features or criteria in the description of the subject of the contract or the award criteria (art. 105 Pzp).
Frequently asked questions#
A public contracting authority can do so only on one condition. It must set quality requirements for at least the main elements of the contract in the description of the subject of the contract (art. 246 ust. 2 Pzp).
The properties of the contractor itself cannot be a criterion. Pzp does, however, allow you to assess the qualifications and experience of the staff assigned to perform the contract, where they can significantly affect the quality of performance.
Yes. A reference to a Polish Standard that transposes a European standard is one way to describe the subject of the contract, and the words “or equivalent” stand next to the standard.
It is a method of assessing cost that counts the costs of use, maintenance and end of life alongside the purchase price. The contracting authority gives the data and the calculation method in the procurement documents.